Protein pills, protein powders… do a simple search on the web and you’ll discover that your options are endless. But which is the better muscle support system? Which can offer you real and credible results?
And that is the question. When you get past all the pros, the cons and the benefits – what is the actual difference between them?
In this post, we plan to delve into the world of protein tablets and show you the best ways to harness their ingredients.
What are protein supplement pills?
Protein capsules are a great way to boost protein synthesis and muscle recovery. They are essentially a type of dietary supplement that can raise your existing protein intake and ensure you are receiving all the essential amino acids you need to encourage natural muscle development.
Now, the amount you need to take varies from source to source, but on average you will need to consume 0.36g of protein (per day) for every pound of body weight.
But that is not all…
Protein supplements are only effective when combined with regular exercise.
Think about it…
Muscle growth occurs with the natural tearing of muscle fibers when you lift weights. It is as these fibers heal i.e. You recover from your workout, that your muscle mass increases. This is why any method of supporting protein synthesis is essential.
By providing your body with these 9 essential amino acids; your body can use it to create its very own protein and build muscle tissue. And this is fantastic news for bodybuilders, because the amount of physical exercise you put your body through, means you need a much higher intake of protein than the average person. Protein pills can provide you with this extra protein.
Who should consider taking them?
Certain individuals may find protein capsules particularly beneficial. Athletes and bodybuilders, for instance, often have high protein goals due to rigorous training schedules. For them, these capsules can serve as a practical way to top up protein needs, especially when traveling or when dietary restrictions make it challenging to meet protein requirements through food alone.
Moreover, protein capsules can be a valuable supplement for people struggling with malnutrition or illness, as regular protein intake is crucial for preventing muscle mass loss and improving energy levels.
Important considerations
While protein capsules can be a useful supplement, they should not replace protein-rich foods such as meat, fish, dairy, soy, beans, and lentils. Whole foods provide additional nutrients that capsules cannot.
It's also important to note that some populations should avoid protein supplements altogether. Individuals with chronic kidney disease, for example, should steer clear of excess protein intake due to potential complications. Pregnant or breastfeeding women should exercise caution as the long-term effects are not well-researched. Additionally, anyone with allergies or intolerances to milk products should carefully check the ingredients of protein capsules.
Incorporating protein capsules into your routine can provide significant benefits, but it's crucial to consider your individual needs and consult with a healthcare professional if you have any concerns.
Here’s the science:
During digestion protein is broken down by dietary enzymes called proteases. The faster protein is broken down, the quicker they can be converted into amino acids to help repair muscle tissue and encourage muscle growth. At the same time, this additional protein can help you to raise your immune system and keep you fitter, stronger and healthier during fitness cycles.
What are sources of protein to produce these pills?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c5f3e/c5f3ef3594ac57ce0cb434f11c418fbfc7715eb8" alt="Protein sources"
Would you believe that the average protein pills contains only 2g of protein – at most?! This is significantly less than protein powders, where – depending on the size of the scoop – you can get around 20-25g of protein.
When you compare them, there is really no competition as you’d need to consume a lot of protein supplement pills to be anywhere close to the level of protein found in powders.
But what type of protein is actually used in these pills? What are the best protein pills made of?
This can vary depending on the manufacturer, but most use either casein or whey. True, there are others you can try – beef, chicken, milk, eggs or liver – but these just aren’t as popular, leaving casein and whey to take the lead. In fact, given a choice whey protein pills win hands down amongst athletes.
This is because whilst both can be digested and absorbed into the body easily enough, whey appears in your bloodstream faster. Whey also appears to have a stronger anabolic effect on muscle growth as it has got more of the essential amino acid leucine.
Either way, if you are struggling to choose a protein pill, we suggest picking one that uses only a high quality source of protein, and that has been paired with other essential vitamins and minerals. This will give your body optimal opportunities to make muscle.
How Protein Capsules Support Those with Dietary Restrictions
Protein capsules offer a convenient solution for people facing dietary challenges or restrictions. They can be particularly beneficial for athletes and bodybuilders who have increased protein needs, as well as for individuals frequently traveling, where sourcing adequate protein can be tricky.
Benefits for Those with Intolerances
For those with multiple food intolerances or allergies, meeting daily protein goals can be a daunting task. Many traditional protein sources, like dairy or soy, might not be suitable. Protein capsules, however, provide an alternative that bypasses these common allergens, making it easier for individuals to meet their nutritional needs without discomfort.
Supplementary, Not Substitutive
It's crucial to remember that while protein capsules can complement one's dietary habits, they should not replace whole foods in the diet. Foods such as meat, fish, beans, and lentils are rich in essential nutrients beyond protein that capsules might not provide. Thus, maintaining a balanced diet is key.
By integrating protein capsules into their routine, individuals with specific dietary needs can ensure they're on the path to meeting their protein requirements efficiently and effectively.
How to use protein pills and for what
The one thing to remember here is that protein pills are NOT a replacement for meals. Sure they can supply you with all the essential amino acids that you need to encourage protein synthesis and muscle development, but they cannot succeed on their own. You need food. Nutrition. Energy.
That is why you should always take protein pills alongside meals to maximize your energy levels.
For optimum results, you should take them at least 2 hours before you work out. This will give your body enough time to digest and utilize the protein within these pills, so you feel energized and ready to perform. Alternatively, you can take them straight after a workout to speed up muscle recovery and repair.
Similarly, it is important to remember that they aren’t dietary supplements and shouldn’t be used for weight loss.
Sure, protein pills can assist with exercise and yes, they can provide your body with the additional fuel it needs to workout harder, but this is not simultaneous with weight loss.
You still have to work out and exercise hard in order to get the weight loss results you’re craving. If anything, the goal of protein pills is to increase your mass.
What is the difference between protein pills and powders?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54c5b/54c5bff57f8bf567c4d5d198eb1db130a3fd6f8f" alt="Protein powder vs pills"
This is the big question: how do protein pills differ from other popular supplements like bars, powders, and cereals?
Protein supplements come in many forms, from bars to powders and even cereals created to slip additional protein into the first and most important meal of the day. However, many find these methods unpalatable, especially the thick, sugar-filled shakes. Protein capsules offer an alternative, aiming to provide your recommended quantity of the nutrient in one, easy-to-swallow pill. It's a novel idea that hasn't fully caught on yet, but it introduces an interesting option for those seeking convenience.
Key Differences
When considering protein pills, powders, bars, and cereals, here are some distinctions to keep in mind:
-
Protein Content:
- Protein pills typically provide only 2g of protein per pill. In contrast, protein powders can offer at least 20g per scoop. Even plant-based powders, like pea protein, contain about 21g for every 28g serving.
-
Dosage and Feasibility:
- There is a dosage limit with pills; taking 10 at once isn't feasible, especially multiple times a day. Don’t do it. It’s not worth it. Plus, there's more to consider.
-
Calories and Meal Replacement:
- Protein shakes contain extra calories, which can assist with weight gain during bulking, unlike protein pills. Shakes can also be used as meal replacements, offering fullness when mixed with milk, water, or fruit juices. Pills can't substitute for meals.
-
Convenience:
- Pills are convenient and portable, without the need for preparation. Powders require prep time, scooping, and mixing, making them less convenient on the go. Bars and cereals, though more straightforward, still don't match the simplicity of pills.
-
Mess and Flavor:
- Powders can be messy, potentially spilling in bags. Pills, being flavorless, avoid the unpleasant aftertastes some powders have.
Similarities
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5bd08/5bd08b62d89b5bebe6da33b08e70ff286c1478ae" alt="Protein powder"
Despite their differences, protein pills and powders share core similarities:
-
Composition:
- Both are essentially the same product presented differently—one as a powder, the other as a pill. They use the same types of protein.
-
Body Processing:
- Your body processes them similarly. Capsule casings dissolve quickly, releasing the protein just like powders do.
By exploring the broader landscape of protein supplements, you can choose the form that best fits your lifestyle and dietary needs. Whether you prioritize convenience, taste, or protein content, understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision.
Pros
- Both can easily be integrated into your bodybuilding cycle AND at different stages of your cycle too. For instance, protein powders are better for bulking as they contain extra calories that can help you to put on weight.
- Both encourage positive health benefits, including: lowered blood pressure; reduced inflammation; improved diabetes and immunity; raised antioxidant properties/defences and falls in bad cholesterol levels.
- Protein powders can help you to feel fuller for longer and can be used as a meal replacement (good for controlling calories and your appetite).
Cons
- Protein pills offer you less protein than eating protein enriched foods. Eggs, milk, chicken, and fish – they all contain more protein than protein pills (and with none of the negative side effects).
- Taken in too high a dosage, protein supplement pills can overload your liver and cause lasting damage e.g. with whey protein you should never take more than 30g in one sitting.
- Excessive use of pills and powders can lead to digestive problems, liver and kidney problems, nausea, pain, bloating, cramping and diarrhea.
- Our bodies can only utilize a limited amount of protein at one time. This means, consume too much protein in one sitting, and this excess protein will become pretty useless.
- Most bodybuilders already consume enough protein in their diet, meaning adding pills or supplements to your cycle won’t always necessarily help you to gain more muscle.
Who Should Avoid Taking Protein Capsules and Why?
Protein capsules are not suitable for everyone. Certain groups should steer clear of these supplements due to potential health risks:
-
Individuals with Pre-Existing Medical Conditions
Those with chronic kidney disease should be cautious. Excessive protein intake can worsen kidney function and lead to further complications. -
Pregnant or Breastfeeding Women
The lack of extensive research on the long-term effects of protein capsules in these groups makes it advisable to avoid them. Ensuring safety for both the mother and child is paramount. -
People with Milk Allergies or Intolerances
Many protein capsules contain milk-derived ingredients. It is crucial for individuals with milk allergies or lactose intolerance to scrutinize labels carefully to prevent adverse reactions.
In essence, if you fall into any of these categories, it's best to consult with a healthcare professional before considering protein capsules as part of your diet.
When to take protein when you workout
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ca82e/ca82e8b6a864094e53207353473e3733633408f3" alt="Weightlifter takes protein before workout"
See what we mean?
When you strip it all away, what you have got are two products that can benefit you in different ways.
Want something that is convenient and easy to use? Take a protein pill. You can easily pop these into your mouth, complete your weightlifting cycle, and watch as the gains appear.
But if you're looking for something beyond capsules, consider these easy-to-consume protein-rich alternatives:
Refreshing Protein Beverages
-
Clear Protein Drinks: These are perfect for those who crave a light, refreshing drink rather than a heavy shake. They often come in fruity flavors and provide a significant protein boost without the lactose.
-
Protein Water: For a hydrating option that sneaks in essential nutrients, protein water offers a blend of protein and amino acids without added sugars or calories. It's a clear, refreshing choice that departs from the typical milky texture of protein shakes.
Tasty Protein Powders
-
Flavored Protein Blends: Enjoy delicious flavors like chocolate salted caramel with these multi-plant-based formulas. Mix them with water or your favorite non-dairy milk for a satisfying and nutritious drink. They're ideal for post-workout recovery or a midday energy boost.
-
Vegan Protein Options: Opt for vegan blends that are free from gluten and soy. These powders often include added benefits like BCAAs and natural enzymes, ensuring you're not just getting protein but a full spectrum of nutrients.
Health-Focused Benefits
Some protein powders are specially formulated to avoid harmful additives and are tested for purity. This ensures you're consuming only the cleanest ingredients, free from heavy metals like mercury and lead.
By exploring these alternatives, you can find a protein source that suits your lifestyle and dietary preferences while still being easy to consume.
Read also: Best Vegan Protein Powder
Bulk Up With CrazyBulk
Take your body to the next level with our range of supplements to increase muscle mass and bulk up FAST. Legal steroid alternatives that give you the energy and strength to pack on serious muscle mass! Find your product now…
Over 299,434 purchases
Over 509,389 bottles sold
Over 30,563,340 pills taken